Showing posts with label comprehensive plan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label comprehensive plan. Show all posts

Comprehensive Plan Amendment Hearing

The Spokane County Planning Commission will be meeting at 9 AM, Thursday, September 16, 2010, to hear public testimony on seven proposed amendments to the Spokane County Comprehensive Plan. The county's web page for these amendments is here.

The amendments include increasing the allowed densities in various locations around the county including Deer Park (10-CPA-02) and Garden Springs (10-CPA-06). There areas of proposed urban growth area expansion on the southeast side of the I-90 Geiger Field (10-CPA-04) and Medical Lake (10-CPA-05) exits. There is a commendable proposal to include the Spokane River as a water trail as part of the county's trail system (10-CPA-07). Additionally, a member of the well-known Douglass family is proposing a conversion of conservation lands into a mine (10-CPA-01).

Disturbingly, there is also a proposed amendment (10-CPA-03) which would bring the western half of the Saltese Flats into the urban growth area, even though it has already been established as a conservation area. At first blush, it seems apparent that this is just a cash grab as the county is investigating the possibility of turning the Saltese Flats back into Saltese Lake as a wetland to help deal with phosphorus problems in the Spokane River. If this property goes into the UGA, then the county would have to pay much more to acquire it. An alternative theory I've heard is that raising it to a higher level allows a greater amount of money to go to the owners in a transfer of development rights (TDR) scheme.

There's an interesting document provided by the folks who are proposing the urban growth area expansions. It is a land quantity analysis which states, in effect, that because the county has violated a COUNTY goal of having 4 units per acre within the urban growth area, it should violate a STATE goal by embracing sprawl.

Imagine that, a local appraiser laying bare Spokane County's violation of the intent of the Growth Management Act.

Four the Future - September 12

Today: Grass-waste-to-energy plant, energy audits, historical preservation, and an environmental public survey.
  • Biofuel project in Spokane County wins $90,000 grant
    Source: Spokesman-Review; September 9, 2010
    Summary: A local company was provided a $90,000 USDA grant to automate the conversion of bluegrass straw into fuel. A 2,000 acre farm could produce enough fuel to recoup the cost of the system in 3-4 years. These electrical generators will become available in about 18 months.
    Opinion: That's a 25% return on investment. You tell me an industry, other than private medical insurance companies and other financial scams, that can do better than that! And now you don't have to burn the straw in the fields. Sounds like an excellent investment in grant monies.
  • Energy audit can lead to big savings
    Source: Spokesman-Review; September 12, 2010
    Summary: Energy audits can save a great deal of money by reducing your need energy without sacrificing comfort. Audits can cause several thousand dollars, and retrofits can cost several thousand more. However, the return on investment can be high, paying off in just a few years. Grants are available to help reduce the cost. You can reduce that cost by reading up.
    Opinion: There are links to other web sites and a book suggestion on the Spokesman site. I know it's hard to contemplate investing thousands of dollars in your home during a recession, especially in a recession focused on the value of your home. But if you still have some equity in your house, this is a good investment to make, since it could potentially save you money each month, and it should only take a few years to pay it off. And it's all money in your pocket after that. You can learn more about starting your own home assessment at the Energy Star web site.
  • Historic preservation chapter will be added to city's plan
    Source: Spokesman-Review; September 11, 2010
    Summary: The City of Millwood has added a historic preservation chapter to its comprehensive plan. Greg Mott said, "We are helping to preserve our community."
    Opinion: Millwood is known for its neighborhood-style physical environment. If the city were to ignore it, nothing in the resulting rules would support it. Soon, main street would be torn down and replaced by a Wal*Mart, simply because the community had failed to say it was important to prevent it. They could make that choice, of course, but it should be a choice, not an oversight. Simply failing to have a historical preservation element in your comprehensive plan is just the same as having one that says, "Tear it down, boys!"
  • State, tribe conducting survey on lake water
    Source: Spokesman-Review; September 12, 2010
    Summary: The State of Idaho and the Coeur d'Alene Tribe are conducting an online survey to see how knowledgeable residents are on water quality and permitting processes. The survey might result in a public education effort.
    Opinion: I know you're all responsible, but merely as a public service announcement, please don't go answer the questions unless you actually live there. Here are some sample questions:
    • What agencies or entities can you think of that have some kind of jurisdiction over activities that affect lake water quality? (multiple choice)
    • What do you know about the Idaho Department of Environmental Quality’s efforts regarding Coeur d’Alene Lake? (essay question)
    • Excess phosphorus and nitrogen flowing into the lake from rivers and streams are a water quality concern (rate 1 to 5)
    Generally, this is the appropriate use of surveys. Personally, I think it's wrong to govern based on opinion polls, but they can be useful to gauge the public's perception of issues.

Four the Future - January 25

On Tap: Building demolition, county sued again, smart meters (audio!), and avoiding stimulus funding.

  • Bid to save warehouse fails
    Source: The Spokesman-Review; January 24, 2010
    Summary: A warehouse on the southeast corner of Riverside and Division will be demolished to make way for an extension of Riverside Avenue. Developer Dan Spalding attempted to save the building, but Washington State University and the City of Spokane are moving forward to preserve the availability of federal transportation dollars and to prevent the loss of parking for SIRTI. Alternatives were considered and found to be unfeasible. Historic preservation advocates say the process was not respected. The new road, to be called Martin Luther King Jr. Way, will connect Riverside to Trent.
    Opinion: First of all, I have to say that I don't have the skills to determine the historical value of this building. However, I should point out that what this building is in the way of is greater automobile use in downtown Spokane. I'm not sure that's of a very high priority. On the other hand, there is an underutilized area between Trent and the rail line. Let's make this even more complex. Part of the conceptual engineering of the light rail also determined that the building to be demolished was also in the way of that project. All in all, a mess. But, I don't think there's anyone here with bad motives. I have found that it is possible in planning that there are two goods which are incompatible with each other. I have also found that early participation in the process is the most effective way of making sure your voice is heard in the final product. Governments need to be better at letting people know what's going on, yes, but each citizen also has a responsibility. If your circle of concern includes historical buildings, then you have a responsibility to make sure you're involved. Because once they're gone, they're gone.
  • Plan change appealed to state hearing board
    Source: The Spokesman-Review; January 21, 2010
    See Also: Four the Future - December 23
    See Also: Four the Future - December 12
    Summary: Spokane County is being sued by Community Addressing Urban Sprawl Excess (CAUSE) in response to the county's recent rezoning of a property near Liberty Lake. The county's comprehensive plan declares the area rural, but Commissioner Mark Richard and an unnamed commissioner voted to allow 6 units per acre, with an additional condition of approval that it not be greater than 5 units per acre.
    Opinion: The unnamed commissioner is Todd Mielke. I'm sure the people up on the south hill would be interested to hear that the commissioners suddenly believe in conditions of approval. To the main point, however: Mielke and Richard ignored the law which only allows one house per 10 acres and now they're being sued for it. No one should be surprised about this. Even Mark Richard knows which way the wind blows when he said that the Eastern Washington Growth Management Hearings Board "has a tendency to decide against the county." Well, duh, Mark. When you ignore the comprehensive plan, that happens. And now he'll be using your tax dollars to defend himself in a losing battle because he wants to make a point to developers that he'll do whatever it takes to help them. But, the citizens of this county should learn a lesson, too: that Mielke and Richard are willing to use your resources against you.
  • Debate: Do Smart Meters Curb Energy Use?
    Source: National Public Radio; January 8, 2010
    Summary: Google is pushing a new device which can track your energy use, and alert you in real time on your desktop. Using it, a person can see what appliances in your house are driving up your energy costs. (Energy is delivered in an odd way. Imagine that when you went into a grocery store, nothing had a price tag on it. Then, at the end of the month, you'd get a summary bill without any itemization.) The theory is that if you were aware of how much energy you were using, you would reduce. However, the debate comes in when one notices how cheap energy prices are. So, perhaps, you would actually use more. The offered solution? Have a machine make those decisions for you.
    Opinion: Energy prices are low to many people, but part of that is only because there are massive externalities (carbon emissions, habitat destruction, etc. which energy companies are not required to mitigate) and federal subsidies which make it cheap. For commercial buildings, at least, I think it's a pretty good idea to have automated energy usage decision making. I also think that energy companies should be allowed to charge based on the time of day so that our peak energy usage can be reduced (although, still regulated!).
  • What We Learned From The Stimulus
    Source: Smart Growth America; retrieved January 25, 2010
    Summary: The amount of work generated by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) was twice as great per dollar for transit than for highway infrastructure. For every billion dollars spent by the federal government, the Surface Transportation Program (STP) created 8,781 job-months and public transportation dollars created 16,419 job-months. Far more dollars were spent on the "shovel ready" STP projects. Texas received six times more STP funds than transit funds, yet transit created 15 percent more jobs. Transit creates more jobs because they spend less money on land and more on people, projects are more complex, and they buy and maintain vehicles.
    Opinion: A lost opportunity for Spokane. Spokane was ready to build a light rail system. Indeed, construction could have been underway as we speak. But certain "conservative" members of the STA board--most egregiously Al French--and STA CEO (and anti-transit activist) E. Susan Meyer used public dollars to withhold information from the public and purposely failed to educate the public about the light rail vote that they had deliberately obfuscated. (Why conservative in quotation marks? They're not actually conservative in this matter. They're anti-transit, which is much different. Many conservatives embrace light rail because it's more efficient than buses and better for economic development. See Paul Weyrich, for example.) In the end, what did they do? They redirected transit funding to other cities, and left people here unemployed. Way to go, "conservatives!"

Four the Future - January 24

Today: Parking policy, greenhouse gas inventory, seeking public input, and climate change planning.

  • Seattle to allow all-day parking lots near light-rail stations, after all
    Source: Seattle Times; January 11, 2010
    Summary: Despite a ordinance which bans it, newly seated Seattle Mayor Mike McGinn will permit all day parking near Link light rail stations. Originally, the plan was to ensure that parking was limited to only a few hours per day. It was intended to help local businesses by making sure available parking wasn't taken up by light rail customers, and to protect local neighborhoods from a flood of commuter traffic. However, local businesses near McGinn's campaign office asked for the change last year. A new proposal will be made later this year.
    Opinion: Parking is a bizarre topic for planners because no one seems to know what amount of parking is appropriate. What I do know is that our policies are wrong, wrong, wrong because they almost always fail because the same policy can be too much in one location, and too little in another. Part of the problem is that parking is free. Well, actually, it isn't: it's built into the cost of every product and service in the nation, but no one recognizes it. And you pay it whether you park for 1 minute or 8 hours or not at all. The more people who know about the seminal work The High Cost of Free Parking (Amazon, $48.28), the better our cities and towns will be. What it argues, in part, is to let the market decide how much parking is worth, rather than having a government mandate to increase the amount of parking and crush the market into worthlessness. I agree.

  • Climate Protection
    Source: City of Vancouver, BC; December 2009
    Summary: the City of Vancouver, British Columbia, has published its Greenhouse Gas Emissions Inventory (PDF, 4.86 MB). It calculates the amount of GHGs that are being emitted by category, such as commercial buildings, residential buildings, and transportation. Vancouver has much to be proud of, as they have reduced GHG emissions to 1990 levels, and the document states the city's belief that it will reach Kyoto goals in 2012. Vancouver has the lowest per capita major city GHG emissions rate in North America at 4.6 metric tonnes. Seattle is 7.1; Portland is 11.9.
    Opinion: In an easily readable form, the City of Vancouver has shown that it's possible to document and track GHG emissions. Everyone should be doing this, because you can change what you can measure.

  • Choices for Cheney
    Source: City of Cheney; January 19, 2010
    Summary: The City of Cheney's comprehensive planning process, Choices for Cheney, is going on the road. the city is displaying data regarding their plan for the year 2030 in various locations around the city, even at multiple locations on Eastern Washington University's campus. Additionally, the displays are staffed to receive in-person input and answer questions.
    Opinion: Plans which are not rooted in public input are worse than useless. For Cheney, in particular, bridging the gap between the university and the rest of the community is important. Kudos to Cheney Community Development Director Brian Jennings for taking it to the people where they learn and work and shop. As a member of the Cheney community, I will be visiting one of the displays so I can reemphasize the importance of housing for low income transitory populations (students!) near the university. As long as the land is available on the edge of the city, there will be more apartments and more transportation headaches (both roads and parking) to deal with. New multifamily housing is mandatory. Where they put it should be obvious.

  • Water planners look ahead
    Source: The Spokesman-Review; January 23, 2010
    Summary: the Army Corps of Engineers is working with the University of Washington's Climate Impacts Group to determine changes in the way dams are used to deal with flooding. As the climate changes, more water is running off in the winter, and less is flowing in the spring and summer. The simulations are anticipating a global change of +3.6 Fahrenheit (+2 degrees Celsius) by 2050.
    Opinion: This is the tip of the melting iceberg. A couple of years ago, reinsurance companies started to raise rates for hurricane damage on the American east coast. It's getting very expensive and in some cases difficult to purchase. And it's becoming necessary in places as far north as Connecticut. This is an example of the market responding to climate change, not scientists. Time to get serious.